A parent spoke at last Monday’s Springs School District Board of Education meeting about the district’s allegedly troubled relationship with its Latino community, which makes up more than 50 percent of the student population.
While another parent, Liz Tatiana Tucci—who is currently in the process of suing the school district for discrimination—translated, Carmen Bustamante told the board and Superintendent John Finello how difficult it has been to stay informed about what is happening in the district due to a lack of translated notices and meetings.
“The Latino community does not feel welcome in the district,” Ms. Bustamante said in Spanish, verging on tears. “We feel like we are strangers to the district and we would like to be included. We would like our notices to be translated.”
Ms. Tucci, who stood beside Ms. Bustamante, pulled out a notice she had received about her daughter’s swimming class. Flipping it over for the board, she showed that there was no translation.
“East Hampton provides translation at board meetings and every notice that goes out to the parents is translated,” said Ms. Tucci, referring to East Hampton School District’s recent addition of a translating system at its board meetings.
In January, East Hampton implemented a system in which a translator speaks into a microphone system connected to wireless headphones to be worn by those in need of Spanish translation.
Ms. Tucci also commented on the confusion and lack of assistance she said Latino parents have faced when going to the district’s office for help.
“Sometimes when they come into the front [of the building] they are not given the opportunity to speak and what they are told is if they don’t understand you have to find somebody,” she told the board, once again translating in part what Ms. Bustamante said.
“According to the Civil Rights Act of 1964 … they must not rely on the students for interpretation,” said Ms. Tucci.
In a statement sent to The Press, Springs School Board President Elizabeth Mendelman said: “The board recognizes that language can be challenging for some of our Hispanic families in navigating the educational system. We continue to bring more resources and tools to help our teachers and staff engage our non-English speaking parents. With smartphone technology and other advances in digital technology we have more opportunities to engage all of our parents. There are many reasons parents can’t attend board meetings and we would like to find ways to remove those barriers.”
Meanwhile, the board released a statement through the public relations firm Syntax stating: “The Springs Union Free School District does not have a practice of discrimination of any kind. We embrace our diverse school community and strive to maintain an environment that promotes tolerance, understanding, respect and equality.”
in the words of Justin Timberlake, "Cry me a river!"
Cheap computers can do most of the translating even.
Are teachers bi-lingual yet or what?
Why not do our best to communicate with ever
No one is forcing anyone to become bi or tri or trans lingual here. You dont have to read the Spanish dude although you may benefit from learning some. Some things are hard, but that's ok.
I'm referring specifically to things like schools, government offices, and other taxpayer funded activities.
Should they all be required by law to accommodate Spanish speakers? That is, should all government documents be available in Spanish? Should government offices be required to have a Spanish translator available?
Google Translate is free. So is Duolingo.
My advice, get off your dupa and use tools that are freely available. Then, "We" don't need to spend money on software, or pay personnel to translate anything.
Additionally, I omitted that Google Chrome with the translate plug-in can easily swap any webpage to the language of one's choice.
All you do is right click, click translate, and choose a language.
We just hint that 'these people are illegal' ...It could be safe to assume that many of 'these' young people were born here and are citizens. Not adapting to this punishes random kids due to the fact that we hate immigrants for some reason. (they dont speak english and act like us)
If a child has a parent or parents who are bigots it's likely that this child will inherit the same warped views of their parents. This is quite the burden to place on a kid.
Because it's a slap in the face to all the people who come here, learn the language, and do things proper. My father is one of those people, along with many members of my family.
Your post, meant to hide your spectacular levels of racism and fear was ineffective.
By HamptonDad (22), Hampton Bays on Mar 25, 16 9:17 PM
The complaint here is that no single group of immigrants should be favored over others. There are students from other nations in the Springs School who are not Hispanic, yes in far lesser number, yet their parents are not provided with translations.
I close by asking you this? Generations of Americans have come here and never received nor dare requested documents in their own language. My grandparents came here and immediately learn the language. Why shouldn't every group?
The United States is a great nation because of its diversity, yet we unite under one language. This is a a tribute to our great history and founders who were the ENGLISH! I'm not English, but I speak English as an American. It is more prejudiced to force English speakers to adapt to a language not native to this nation.